Brooklyn and The Butcher

Recently moved to Southern Indiana, so I’m not familiar with the dining scene pre-2019. But what I have heard by locals is that this restaurant revolutionized the restaurant scene in New Albany when it opened. My first experience was a breakfast on a Sunday morning, fun buffet environment with hearty and flavorful waffle specialties. Second experience was to check out the basement ‘speakeasy’ - really a hidden gem that is quiet, candle-lit, and well-appointed. Third experience was for a dinner, where I was amazed to see the range of steak options- far more than expected and sirloin that I ordered was excellent. Great spot for date night or family/celebration dinner. Bar is separate from the restaurant and has a TV, and knowledgeable drink staff.

We just went there to celebrate my bfs bday. He loves a perfectly cooked stake and was really happy with it. But please do yourself a favor and order the tuna tartare, it is just awesome!

Over price for the quality of food served. Ordered omelets never came to table. Asked server where they might be , she went to check . When she returned she said they were running behind because of party downstairs. We had completed our meals and definitely ready to leave. The manager did give us 50% off the meal.